| Year | Name | College |
| 2022 | Teegan Tschampel | Condordia University |
| 2022 | Nate Lendt | Doane University |
| 2021 | Justin Henry | Alderson Broaddus University |
| 2020 | Darrell Mason | Minnesota State University |
| 2020 | Cameron Mayes-Butler | Indiana Tech University |
| 2020 | Rozell Baker | McKendree University |
| 2020 | Dennis McNeal | Brewton-Parker College |
| 2020 | Cardeionte Wilson | Southern Illinois University Edwardsville |
| 2019 | Charles Griffin | Grand View University |
| 2019 | Pat Depiazza | Cumberland University |
| 2019 | Carter Cox | Cumberland University |
| 2019 | Myron Crawford | Upper Iowa University |
| 2018 | Kahlyn Chatman | Graceland University |
| 2018 | Anthony Collins | Limestone University |
| 2018 | Justin Folley | Upper Iowa University |
| 2018 | Steven Lawrence | Grand View University |
| 2018 | Javier Moreno | Loras College |
| 2018 | Jaycie Rudd | Graceland University |
| 2018 | Tim Young | Old Dominion University |
| 2017 | Jordan Gundrum | Upper Iowa University |
| 2017 | Gary Whitaker | Grand View University |
| 2017 | Devonte Williams | Midland University |
| 2016 | Bobby Alexander | University of Wisconsin Parkside |
| 2016 | Dalonte Holland | Missouri Valley College |
| 2016 | Matthew Kirkland | Limestone College |
| 2016 | Terry Martin | Missouri Valley College |
| 2016 | Sadarriss Patterson | Missouri Valley College |
| 2016 | Jermaine Pryor | Missouri Valley College |
| 2016 | Marcus Thompson | Missouri Valley College |
| 2016 | Tepra Wright | Northern Illinois University |
| 2015 | DeShun Brown | Arizona State |
| 2015 | Steven Candley | Central College |
| 2015 | Kevin Cooper | McKendree University |
| 2015 | Edwin Wilson | Limestone University |
| 2015 | Sharod Wilson | University of Dubuque |
| 2014 | Eric Franklin | Concordia University |
| 2014 | Mike Guassarson | Coe College |
| 2014 | Dortanyia McIntyre | Concordia University |
| 2014 | Da'Wayne Robertson | Minnesota State Mankato |
| 2014 | John Shadursky | Briar Cliff University |
| 2014 | Mike Stewart | Johnson Wales University |
| 2013 | Josh DaSilveira | Arizona State University |
| 2013 | Tyler Lashbrook | Morningside College |
| 2012 | Andrew Clark | Grandview |
| 2011 | Jean Augustine | Minot State University |
| 2011 | Ray Bryant | University of Dubuque |
| 2011 | Vinny Campanile | Kutztown |
| 2011 | Kyle Dellamo | Kutztown |
| 2011 | Ali Khan | Minot State University |
| 2011 | Ethan Montang | William Penn University |
| 2011 | Steve Moreno | Utah Valley State |
| 2011 | Logan Poe | Grandview |
| 2011 | Onni Prestidge | University of Northern Iowa |
| 2010 | Robert Hererra | Minot State University |
| 2010 | Ryan Harrenstein | University of Northern Iowa |
| 2010 | Damonte Stonger | University of Northern Iowa |
| 2010 | Stanley Lattimore | Oklahoma City University |
| 2010 | Ruben Perez | Oklahoma City University |
| 2009 | Bojan Djukic | Grandview College |
| 2009 | Jeremy McCoy | Lindsey Wilson College |
| 2008 | Tyler Bowling | Augsburg College |
| 2008 | Ryan Bormann | UW-Platteville |
| 2008 | Brian Telgenhoff | Coe College |
| 2008 | Eric Thaveonkham | Grandview College |
| 2008 | Trevor Gehringer | Grandview College |
| 2008 | Chad Kriz | Grandview College |
| 2008 | Keith Klink | Lindsey Wilson College |
| 2008 | Justin Dixon | UW-LaCrosse |
| 2008 | Mike Freeman | Western State |
| 2007 | Micah Keller | Upper Iowa University |
| 2007 | Cole Spree | Northwestern College |
| 2007 | Claudell Noel | Northwestern College |
| 2007 | Josh Miller | UW-Whitewater |
| 2006 | Shamar Haynes | William Penn |
| 2006 | Damian Swielik | American University |
| 2005 | Josh Pratt | Buena Vista |
| 2005 | Nick Deskman | Morningside |
| 2005 | Mitch Zmolek | Coe College |
| 2005 | Jeremy Ascherl | Wisconsin Whitewater |
| 2004 | Mario Gakanakis | University of Iowa |
| 2004 | Ken Prophete | Cumberland College |
| 2003 | Nick Hiller | Kent State University |
| 2003 | Dustin Bliven | Wartburg College |
| 2003 | Kyle Wellington | NE Missouri State |
| 2002 | Rob Pilcher | Briar Cliff College |
| 2002 | Bart Mehlert | Wartburg College |
| 2002 | Erik Jones | Ohio University |
| 2002 | Brian Herschberger | Dana College |
| 2001 | Tony Fratzke | Minnesota State |
| 2001 | Bill Stuart | Wartburg College |