| 2024 All-Conference | ||||
| Adrian Palos LB | ||||
| Xavian Andrews DB | ||||
| Nigel Cheeks Return Specialist | ||||
| 2023 All-Conference | ||||
| Adrian Palos LB | ||||
| Sean Martin DB | ||||
| Dominic McCarren WR | ||||
| Isaiah Maumalanga OL | ||||
| 2022 All-Conference | ||||
| Malcolm Gillie | WR | |||
| Darrius Jackson | WR | |||
| Kariem Al Soufi | OL | |||
| Michael Acri | LB | |||
| 2021 (Fall) All-Conference | ||||
| Deivi Martinez | OL | |||
| Malcolm Bryant | DL | |||
| Jonathan Forson | DB | |||
| Malcolm Gillie | WR | |||
| 2021 (Spring) All-Conference | ||||
| Deivi Martinez | OL | |||
| Davon Sears | DL | |||
| Andrew Behm | LB | |||
| Jonathan Forson | DB | |||
| Ja'Ron Early | RB | |||
| 2019 All-Conference | ||||
| Jake Poetzl | DL | |||
| Keegan Glaus | LB | |||
| Jaydon Glenn | P | |||
| Caden Coulson | OL | |||
| 2018 All-Conference | ||||
| Jordan Foster | WR | |||
| Solomon Pierce | OL | |||
| Ali Shockley | LB | |||
| Keonte Schad | DL | |||
| Marchalo Judge | DB | |||
| Naeem Smith | DB | |||
| 2017 All-Conference | ||||
| Tekendrick Roberson | RB | |||
| Ben Rooney | WR | |||
| Drew Greenhaw | WR | |||
| Matt Platko | OL | |||
| Logan McDonald | OL | |||
| Jevonte Arius | LB | |||
| Detemetrius Caddell | DL | |||
| Keonte Schad | DL | |||
| Naeem Smith | DB | |||
| Derek Nixon | LS | |||
| 2016 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Louy Compton | DL | ||
| Reggie Miles | DL | |||
| Justin Wright | K | |||
| Ryan Guthrie | LB | |||
| Nikolas Ricks | LB | |||
| Rob Castaneda | OL | |||
| Tanis Joseph | OL | |||
| Ben Russell | OL | |||
| Jamarius Way | WR | |||
| 2nd Team | Javonte Arius | DB | ||
| Paris Chambers | DB | |||
| Elijah Jones | DB | |||
| Michael Maher | DL | |||
| Demetrius Caddell | LB | |||
| Ethan Barnett | RB | |||
| Tekendrick Roberson | RB | |||
| Juwan Petit-Frere | WR | |||
| Honorable Mention | Devon Russell | DB | ||
| Lucas Depriest | DL | |||
| Edvin Kovacevic | OL | |||
| Lamont Toney | QB | |||
| 2015 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | KeAaris Ardley | DB | ||
| Ryan Guthrie | LB | |||
| David Goldsby | OL | |||
| JuJuan Young-Battle | QB | |||
| Xavier Washpun | RB | |||
| Johnathan Boone | WR | |||
| Jerry Jones | WR | |||
| Jaleel Scott | WR | |||
| 2nd Team | Devin Brockington | DB | ||
| Alex Caldwell | DB | |||
| Tyler Chaudoin | DB | |||
| Louy Compton | DL | |||
| Brandon McCracken | DT | |||
| Royce Peterson | LB | |||
| DJ Loving | OL | |||
| Cedric McCoy | OL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Dontrell Johnson | CB | ||
| Pedro Gomez | DL | |||
| Dustin Caldwell | RB | |||
| 2014 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Tyrian Taylor | WR/RE | ||
| Xavier Washpun | RB | |||
| Brian Steffensmeier | LT | |||
| Cedric McCoy | RT | |||
| Angelo Sumler | MLB | |||
| Josh Kirk | SS | |||
| Dayton Balvanz | P | |||
| 2nd Team | Demarius Davis | QB | ||
| Tad Steffensmeier | WR | |||
| Kevin Thompson | DE | |||
| Terry Mooty | MOLB | |||
| Dawayne Pruitt | OLB | |||
| Kearvis Ardley | FS | |||
| Honorable Mention | Zabreion Gunter | DE/DT | ||
| Marquan Clayton | LG | |||
| Tyler Chaudoin | DE | |||
| O'Daryl Davis-Douglas | CB | |||
| Lachel Durant | CB | |||
| 2013 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Corry O'Meally | DB | ||
| Devante Averette | LB | |||
| Irving Steele | LB | |||
| 2nd Team | Dayton Balvantz | K/P | ||
| La'More Wise | LB | |||
| Brian Steffensmeier | OL | |||
| Trey Gilbert | RB | |||
| Oscar Ross | WR | |||
| Honorable Mention | Terrell Simmons | DB | ||
| Ciavy Wiles | WR | |||
| 2012 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Ryan Johnson | OL | ||
| Terrell Simmons | DB | |||
| Irving Steele | LB | |||
| Ciavy Wiles | WR | |||
| Amari Williams | TE | |||
| 2nd Team | DeVante Averette | LB | ||
| DeMarkus Carey | DB | |||
| Jordan Doyle | QB | |||
| Trey Gilbert | RB | |||
| Jordan Harrington | OL | |||
| JT Tolbert | WR | |||
| Honorable Mention | Corry O'Meally | DB | ||
| Eric Pruitt | OL | |||
| 2011 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Will Cornelius | LB | ||
| Brennan Lauterbach | LB | |||
| Brandon Lenehan | LB | |||
| 2nd Team | Tim Bennett | DB | ||
| Chris Bullerman | TE | |||
| Aaron Coghlan | LB | |||
| Hunter Elvidge | P | |||
| TJ James | RB | |||
| Seth McGowan | DB | |||
| Reid Nuss | QB | |||
| Blake Pennock | LB | |||
| Jay Schmit | ATH | |||
| Oliver Schmitz | LB | |||
| 2010 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | John Rabe | TE | ||
| Dexter Holmes | WR | |||
| Chris Charles | DB | |||
| Travon Montgomery | LB | |||
| 2nd Team | Ken Bishop | DT | ||
| Willie Tindal | QB | |||
| TJ James | RB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Joe Hoback | OL | ||
| Nick Eversmeyer | OL | |||
| Matt Steffensmeier | OL | |||
| 2009 All-Region | ||||
| 1st Team | Tirrell Rennie | QB | ||
| Quintin Robinson | WR | |||
| Matt Steffensmeier | OL | |||
| John Rabe | TE | |||
| Stanfred Philpot | DB | |||
| Aaron Strumksit | DL | |||
| LJ Gamblin | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Tyrell Austin | RB | ||
| John Wallace | RB | |||
| Jonathon Aiken | WR | |||
| Andre Thomas | WR | |||
| Luke Smith | WR | |||
| Ricaldo Henry | OL | |||
| Joe Hoback | OL | |||
| Nick Eversmeyer | OL | |||
| Allan Wallace | OL | |||
| Markinley St. Fort | DB | |||
| Miraldo Michael | DL | |||
| Gus Mormann | DL | |||
| Neal Issa | LB | |||
| Shawn Krusey | P | |||
| Jamison Disalvo | K | |||
| 2008 All-Region | ||||
| 1st Team | Quintin Robinson | WR | ||
| Tirrell Rennie | QB | |||
| Aaron Strumski | DT | |||
| LJ Gamblin | LB | |||
| Jeff Meyer | OL | |||
| Corey Wright | OL | |||
| Joe Forgy | DE | |||
| Honorable Mention | Jacob Peterson | LB | ||
| Aaron Hilliard | LB | |||
| Tyrell Austin | RB | |||
| Jonathon Aiken | WR | |||
| Thaad Thompson | DB | |||
| Gus Mormann | DE | |||
| Caleb Schwieger | OL | |||
| Shawn Martin | TE | |||
| Gary Cook | DT | |||
| 2007 All-Region | ||||
| 1st Team | CJ Francis | RB | ||
| Jeff Meyer | C | |||
| Joe Morris | RB | |||
| Luke Brocka | TE | |||
| Theo Jones | CB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Jeremy Crowder | LB | ||
| Jessie Bundrage | QB | |||
| Joe Forgy | LB | |||
| Kori Moore | LB | |||
| Terrell Tillman | CB | |||
| 2006 All-Region | ||||
| 1st Team | CJ Jones | CB | ||
| Corey Reed | LB | |||
| Gerald Reed | WR | |||
| James Jones | S | |||
| Janssen Hayes | OL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Adam Behrends | S | ||
| Brandon Dorsett | LB | |||
| Chris Miller | CB | |||
| Curtis Thommen | OL | |||
| Dexter Baldwin | WR | |||
| Ian Gilworth | QB | |||
| JJ Henderson | DE | |||
| Luke Brocka | TE | |||
| Tyler Pacha | FB | |||
| Zach Wilson | DE | |||
| 2005 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Tony Edwards | WR | ||
| Cody Stockdale | LB | |||
| Joe Hall | LB | |||
| Sid Nagle | OL | |||
| Onesi Lino | DE | |||
| Honorable Mention | Monroe Tillman | DB | ||
| Zack Thomas | QB | |||
| Marcus Dawson | RB | |||
| Chris Beekman | WR | |||
| CJ Jones | DB | |||
| Siaosi Lino | LB | |||
| 2004 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Walter Smith | RB | ||
| Brady Robbins | OL | |||
| Dylan White | LB | |||
| Chance Jenkins | DB | |||
| Jordan Gartner | DB | |||
| Marcus Brooks | LB | |||
| Matt Cunningham | DL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Zack Thomas | QB | ||
| Mike Magarino | QB | |||
| Luis Inguanzo | TE | |||
| Josh Firstley | FB | |||
| Matt Warren | WR | |||
| Zach Wyatt | OL | |||
| Jesse Matteson | OL | |||
| Tony Edwards | WR | |||
| Kevin Bugg | WR | |||
| Eustace Webster | OL | |||
| Mike Figgers | LB | |||
| Brian Austin | DL | |||
| Onesi Lino | DL | |||
| CJ Boram | DB | |||
| Monroe Tillman | DB | |||
| 2003 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Tom Anthony | WR | ||
| Jordan Sallis | TE | |||
| Adam Hughes | DL | |||
| Matt Rodemeyer | DL | |||
| John Clark | LB | |||
| Tanner Varner | DB | |||
| David Lorrie | P | |||
| Honorable Mention | Kevin Bugg | WR | ||
| John Washington | WR | |||
| Junior Alexis | QB | |||
| Marcus Brooks | LB | |||
| Josh Firstley | FB | |||
| Dylan White | LB | |||
| Toryan White | LB | |||
| Bryan Olsen | OL | |||
| Jeremy Hoffpauir | OL | |||
| Kevin Pope | DL | |||
| 2002 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | James Dotson | LB | ||
| Aaron Johnson | DL | |||
| Adam Hughes | DL | |||
| Terrence Jones | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Essic Sanders | RB | ||
| Nathan Oberender | WR | |||
| Frankie Jenkins | WR | |||
| Jeremy Hoffpauir | OL | |||
| Matt Rodemeyer | DL | |||
| Jamall Simpson | DL | |||
| Tanner Varner | DB | |||
| Erskine Jude | LB | |||
| 2001 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Scott Rislov | QB | ||
| Charles Clark | WR | |||
| Tommie Powell | DL | |||
| Jonathan Harrell | LB | |||
| Terrence Bell | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Latorence Williams | OL | ||
| Rian Thompson | RB | |||
| Mike Codie | RB | |||
| Nathan Oberender | WR | |||
| James Dotson | LB | |||
| Jamall Simpson | DL | |||
| Terrence Jones | DB | |||
| Santino Turnbow | DB | |||
| Joe Williams | DB | |||
| Jeff Douglas | P | |||
| 2000 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Mario Ivy | DL | ||
| Tyler Luebke | OL | |||
| Jonathan Harrell | LB | |||
| Demetrius Whitfield | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Rian Thompson | RB | ||
| Roman Daggett | OL | |||
| Tommie Powell | DL | |||
| Michael Jackson | LB | |||
| Martin DeCamp | LB | |||
| 1999 Not Available | ||||
| 1998 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Kyle Gorsh | QB | ||
| Bonner Tuinstra | DL | |||
| Jay Koedam | LB | |||
| 1997 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Zach Smith | TE | ||
| Jason McIntire | OL | |||
| DeAndre Harris | DL | |||
| Allan Novak | LB | |||
| 1996 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Corey Willie | WR | ||
| Kevius Clark | QB | |||
| Damon Stewart | DB | |||
| Joe Soukup | LB | |||
| Reggie Williams | DL | |||
| Jomone Fields | DL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Al Starks | OL | ||
| Kevin Wood | OL | |||
| Derek Moore | OL | |||
| Terry Dixon | OL | |||
| Jareese Williams | WR | |||
| Zack Smith | TE | |||
| DeAndre Harris | DL | |||
| 1995 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Wayne Thomson | OL | ||
| Felix Richardson | DL | |||
| Steve Jenkins | LB | |||
| George Smith | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Matt Chapman | OL | ||
| Dan Anderson | DL | |||
| Matt Gardner | DB | |||
| 1994 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Felix Richardson | DL | ||
| Aaron Woods | DB | |||
| 1993 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Janssen Spain | DL | ||
| Shawn Lang | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Jon Lee | LB | ||
| Aaron Woods | DB | |||
| Anthony Woodson | DL | |||
| Wade Kroeze | LB | |||
| 1992 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Wade Wetlaufer | QB | ||
| Raymond Taylor | RB | |||
| Kahn Powell | WR | |||
| Ghaton Ross | OL | |||
| Matt Lippman | WR | |||
| Chris Atwood | P | |||
| Ken Duilio | DL | |||
| Massilon Boyd | LB | |||
| Sidney Madison | DB | |||
| 1991 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Troy Hansen | OL | ||
| Matt Lippman | LB | |||
| Tony Teague | TE | |||
| Joe Allen | DL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Bernard Wright | DB | ||
| Massilon Boyd | LB | |||
| Jermaine Reed | LB | |||
| Shaft Baker | LB | |||
| Kevin Busch | DL | |||
| Ken Duilio | DL | |||
| Sidney Madison | DB | |||
| Ghaton Ross | OL | |||
| Jay Grey | OL | |||
| Charles Davis | RB | |||
| Randy Lyons | RB | |||
| Al Randolph | QB | |||
| DDrew Brandt | Ol | |||
| Herb McMath | OL | |||
| 1990 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Ruel Kierstein | OL | ||
| Kelley Yancey | RB | |||
| Brian Preston | RB | |||
| Ben Hansen | TE | |||
| Lance Keller | DL | |||
| Cory Landeen | DL | |||
| Arthur Davis | LB | |||
| Jason Surlas | DB | |||
| Mike Smith | K | |||
| Honorable Mention | Robert Ritter | OL | ||
| Scott Wagenknecht | Ol | |||
| Troy Hansen | OL | |||
| Charles Miles | RB | |||
| David Lewis | WR/KR | |||
| Ted Van Hyfte | LB | |||
| Daikiel Shorts | RB | |||
| 1989 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Mike Cole | DL | ||
| Arthur Davis | LB | |||
| Ernie Beler | LB | |||
| Eric Harris | DB | |||
| Kevin Rosenkrans | OL | |||
| Eric Roberts | OL | |||
| Bryan Thomsen | OL | |||
| Jason Budinger | OL | |||
| Charles Miles | RB | |||
| Mike Knuth | K | |||
| Honorable Mention | Chuck Fox | RB | ||
| Troy Travis | QB | |||
| Lewis Haley | RB | |||
| Dale Carter | DB | |||
| Sam Williams | LB | |||
| Dustin Reeves | OL | |||
| Lance Keller | DL | |||
| Pete Pirillo | DL | |||
| Fred Washington | TE | |||
| 1988 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Jim Bodensteiner | OL | ||
| Randy Mehrl | OL | |||
| James Bradley | WR/P | |||
| Steve Lester | WR | |||
| Robert Rivers | RB | |||
| Martin Moore | DL | |||
| Brad Wymer | DL | |||
| Terrell Blanks | LB | |||
| Melvin Coleman | LB | |||
| Dale Carter | DB | |||
| Emmanuel Powell | DB | |||
| Kevin Hart | RB | |||
| 1987 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Jeff Herter | DL | ||
| Robbie Harris | DL | |||
| Bruce Lane | DL | |||
| Greg Taylor | LB | |||
| Melvin Coleman | LB | |||
| James Vernon | DB | |||
| Jason Hunt | OL | |||
| Doug Bone | OL | |||
| Shawn Mattraw | OL | |||
| Steve Lester | WR | |||
| Ulysses Bentley | RB | |||
| Dan Miller | K | |||
| James Bradley | P | |||
| 1986 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Bret Dirks | OL | ||
| Dale Wriedt | OL | |||
| Tim Hunt | OL | |||
| Steve Hicks | WR | |||
| Darren Myles | RB | |||
| Carnell Washington | DL | |||
| Bob Hoffman | DL | |||
| William Stewart | LB | |||
| James Vernon | DB | |||
| 1985 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Jackie Armstrong | WR | ||
| Tony Cox | P | |||
| Tim Hanks | DB | |||
| Maurice Hill | RB | |||
| Barry Hoffmeister | OL | |||
| Keith Jones | WR | |||
| Jake Schloesser | K | |||
| Toren Schonyers | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Dennis Preston | OL | ||
| Jim Arneson | QB | |||
| Darrin Tate | LB | |||
| Tony Seedorf | DB | |||
| Mike Schultz | DB | |||
| Tim Judson | LB | |||
| Jason Jones | DB | |||
| 1984 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Kevin Ringer | RB | ||
| Nate Blanks | WR | |||
| Jody Malone | OL | |||
| Mike Morrison | OL | |||
| Richard Brown | DB | |||
| Myron Keppy | DL | |||
| 1983 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Dave Murphy | TE | ||
| Derrick Harden | WR | |||
| Brad White | QB | |||
| Alton Long | RB | |||
| Mark Caballero | OL | |||
| Kendal Barz | LB | |||
| Ken Seminick | LB | |||
| Tim Moses | DB | |||
| Jimmie Drayton | DB | |||
| Mickey Hale | P | |||
| Pat Johnson | K | |||
| 1982 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Mark Thomsen | QB | ||
| Steve Hansley | WR | |||
| Brad Sullivan | LB | |||
| Robert Oliver | DL | |||
| Kendal Barz | LB | |||
| Jerry Malone | OL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Curtis Frazier | OL | ||
| Brian Funke | OL | |||
| Anthony Townes | DL | |||
| Brian Carrott | DB | |||
| Mike McAreavey | DB | |||
| Steve Shaw | LB | |||
| Wayne Love | RB | |||
| 1981 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Tony Floyd | OL | ||
| Brad Zeitner | QB | |||
| Lamont Wagner | RB | |||
| Jim Benson | DL | |||
| Kent Hartwig | LB | |||
| Tim Leppla | LB | |||
| Don Wilson | DB | |||
| Phil Montandon | P | |||
| Honorable Mention | Chris Burback | WR | ||
| Dan Schuck | LB | |||
| Pat Kelley | FB | |||
| Dave Storm | OL | |||
| Ken Schuck | TE | |||
| Bill Swats | WR | |||
| Kevin Murray | DB | |||
| 1980 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Bryan Smith | WR | ||
| Tony Greene | RB | |||
| Frank Jacobs | RB | |||
| Todd Stout | QB | |||
| Paul Fairchild | OL | |||
| Julius Holt | DL | |||
| Jimmy Janes | DL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Mark Murphy | OL | ||
| Scott Mayberry | OL | |||
| Steve Strannan | OL | |||
| Darryl Goosby | TE | |||
| James Locke | LB | |||
| 1979 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Jim Pekar | DL | ||
| Tom Olson | LB | |||
| Dave Cayler | DB | |||
| Jeff Stevens | OL | |||
| Tom Strang | OL | |||
| James Walker | WR | |||
| Tony Greene | RB | |||
| Mark Dolan | QB | |||
| Brad Zumbach | P | |||
| 1978 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Steve Watson | OL | ||
| Todd Speer | PK | |||
| Nick Sommers | DL | |||
| Scott Jensen | DL | |||
| Tom Ricks | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Thad Strub | TE | ||
| Jim Pekar | DL | |||
| Bernie Pomlee | DL | |||
| Lawrence Williams | DB | |||
| Pat Dunn | OL | |||
| Varrick Wilson | WR | |||
| Mike Moody | OL | |||
| 1977 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Rich Gebhart | OL | ||
| Rocky Hugee | OL | |||
| Denny Wagner | OL | |||
| Greg Smith | WR | |||
| Walter Grant | QB | |||
| 2nd Team | Mike Roth | DL | ||
| Tim Walls | DL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Craig Both | DL | ||
| Tony Roberts | RB | |||
| Alonzo Lee | LB | |||
| Ken Winbush | DL | |||
| 1976 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Darrell Hobbs | DL | ||
| Tim Wells | DL | |||
| Mark Zeller | LB | |||
| Bill Fisher | DB | |||
| Greg Calhoun | TE | |||
| Dave Reiber | OL | |||
| Reggie Hall | OL | |||
| Willie Lewis | WR | |||
| Maurice Jackson | RB | |||
| Walter Grant | QB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Larry Ubben | OL | ||
| Milton Turner | RB | |||
| Greg Smith | WR | |||
| Bill Marino | DL | |||
| Craig Both | DL | |||
| Len Fagen | DB | |||
| 1975 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Dennis Bullock | WR | ||
| Bill Fisher | DB | |||
| Gary Evans | OL | |||
| Bill Dolan | QB | |||
| Rodrick Williams | RB | |||
| Darrell Hobbs | DL | |||
| Rod Mather | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Rod Sears | DB | ||
| Bill Marino | DL | |||
| Willie Lewis | WR | |||
| Kevin Barz | OL | |||
| Reggie Hall | OL | |||
| Preston Byers | RB | |||
| 1974 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | John Blazek | LB | ||
| Dave Green | OL | |||
| Carlos Ward | LB | |||
| Rodrick Williams | RB | |||
| Gary Evans | OL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Jack Specht | OL | ||
| Charlie Williams | WR | |||
| Bobby Scott | RB | |||
| Scott Garner | OL | |||
| Larry Ubben | TE | |||
| 1973 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Mel Dunklin | WR | ||
| George Robinson | QB | |||
| Walter Krebs | DL | |||
| Brian Ford | LB | |||
| Tom Hinton | OB | |||
| Jim Off | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Randy Diehl | OL | ||
| Jim Just | OL | |||
| Robert Nelson | OL | |||
| David DuPree | RB | |||
| Lou Chadwick | DL | |||
| Jerry Hoff | DL | |||
| Wes Gordon | DL | |||
| Marcus Wilkison | LB | |||
| Spencer Welsh | DB | |||
| 1972 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Don Joyce | LB | ||
| Emmit Doolan | DB | |||
| Sy Bassett | DB | |||
| Kim Taylor | PK | |||
| 2nd Team | Manny McGuire | TE | ||
| Bob Nelson | OL | |||
| Jim Just | OL | |||
| Mel Dunklin | WR | |||
| David DuPree | RB | |||
| Bruce Barnes | WR | |||
| Doug Voss | DL | |||
| Steve Craig | P | |||
| Honorable Mention | John Biersner | QB | ||
| Dave Diehl | DL | |||
| 1971 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | John Isom | OL | ||
| Delbert Connors | OL | |||
| John Tovar | QB | |||
| Don Willingham | RB | |||
| John Garcia | DL | |||
| Marty Smith | LB | |||
| Mike Lemon | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Dennis Dickey | WR | ||
| Mike Adams | OL | |||
| Emmit Doolan | RB | |||
| Scott Sickles | DL | |||
| Rick Peterson | DL | |||
| Sy Bassett | DB | |||
| Bill Florence | DB | |||
| David Graham | DB | |||
| 1970 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Pat Scott | OL | ||
| Matt Catalina | OL | |||
| Bob Haydock | OL | |||
| Ralph Evanovich | WR | |||
| Turner Phillips | RB | |||
| Lynn Stickfort | DL | |||
| Marty Smith | LB | |||
| Doug Lee | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Art Warner | WR | ||
| Delbert Conners | OL | |||
| Bob Brewster | RB | |||
| Don Willingham | RB | |||
| Marshall McCullough | OL | |||
| Melvin Parker | LB | |||
| Wyatt Jones | DB | |||
| 1969 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | John Blessman | OL | ||
| Gilbert Sanford | RB | |||
| Bob Brewster | FB | |||
| Harold Bassett | DL | |||
| Tom Surlas | LB | |||
| Jim Hinton | DB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Harold Queisser | QB | ||
| Marty Baker | DB | |||
| Mark O'Donnell | DL | |||
| 1968 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Lee Wykle | QB | ||
| Mike Palmer | RB | |||
| Dick Strittmater | OL | |||
| Steve Hornung | LB | |||
| Bob Rudd | DB | |||
| 1967 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Dwight Sims | WR | ||
| Kent Holmgaard | OL | |||
| Stan Whitman | OL | |||
| Mike Palmer | RB | |||
| Steve Hornung | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Lee Wykle | QB | ||
| Gar McCormick | DL | |||
| 1966 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Bob Hampton | OL | ||
| Marv Johnson | WR | |||
| Doug Goske | OL | |||
| Dave Mundt | FB | |||
| Duane Bieghley | QB | |||
| Tom Kramer | DL | |||
| Bob Best | DB | |||
| Dan Goddard | LB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Bill Calloway | RB | ||
| 1965 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | John Gross | QB | ||
| Bill Smith | RB | |||
| Bob Hampton | OL | |||
| Gordon Weber | OL | |||
| 2nd Team | Marv Johnson | WR | ||
| Ed Nelson | OL | |||
| 1964 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | John Lawson | WR | ||
| Mark Biechley | RB | |||
| 2nd Team | Vaughn Butterbrodt | WR | ||
| Keith Schmitz | OL | |||
| Warren Huel | OL | |||
| Honorable Mention | Bill Smith | RB | ||
| 1963 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Jim Growden | OL | ||
| Jim Scallon | OL | |||
| Jim Murra | OL | |||
| John Lawson | RE | |||
| 2nd Team | Roger Wykle | QB | ||
| Honorable Mention | Bob Wilcinski | FB | ||
| Dan Patterson | LE | |||
| 1962 All-Conference | ||||
| 1st Team | Dan Patterson | LE | ||
| Gary Wiggins | OL | |||
| Dennis Ubben | OL | |||
| Ed Eichorn | OL | |||
| Bob Wilcinski | FB | |||
| Swede Belgarde | RB | |||
| 2nd Team | Jim Growden | OL | ||
| Carroll Paulson | OL | |||
| Tom Gerard | RB | |||
| Honorable Mention | Stan Granzow | RB | ||
*** |
||||