| 2020 | Alec Oberhauser | Doane University | NAIA |
| Sam Urness | Cornell College | NCAA DIII | |
| Keaton Taylor | Judson State | NAIA | |
| Josh Donaldson | Lincoln Christian University | NAIA | |
| Tate Muilenburg | University of Tampa | NCAA DII | |
| 2019 | Jamal Antoine | Louisiana College | NCAA DIII |
| 2018 | LaVeechie Williams | Clark University | NAIA |
| Darius Lasley | Clark University | NAIA | |
| Tristan Forysth | California Baptist | NCAA DI | |
| 2017 | Keeon Johnson | Dakota State University | NAIA |
| Maurice Arrington | Dakota State University | NAIA | |
| Octavius O'Large | Waldorf College | NAIA | |
| Mike Evans | Mount Mercy University | NAIA | |
| Amel Kuljuhovic | Cal-State Fullerton | NCAA Dl | |
| 2015 | Kalehl Brown | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA DII |
| Kalund Brown | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA DII | |
| David Dep | Our Lady of Lake University | NAIA | |
| Marquice Jones | College of Coastal Georgia | NAIA | |
| Marquis McThay | William Penn University | NAIA | |
| Justin McFadden | Florida National University | NAIA | |
| 2014 | Tonnie Collier | Texas Southern University | NCAA DI |
| DaQuan Moore | Mount Mercy College | NAIA | |
| Robert Lee | Tarleton State | NCAA DII | |
| 2013 | Malcolm Canada | Auburn University | NCAA DI |
| Jared Fulks | Baker University | NAIA | |
| 2012 | Mario Donaldson | Northwest Nazerene | NCAA DII |
| Charles Ieans | Coppin State University | NCAA DI | |
| Alfreeman Flowers | Missouri Southern | NCAA DII | |
| Darren Galloway | St. Ambrose University | NAIA | |
| 2011 | Bill Freeman | Nebraska Omaha | NCAA DI |
| Jacques Coleman | Nebraska Omaha | NCAA DI | |
| Tut Jikany | Dallas Baptist University | NCAA DII | |
| Derryl Nash | Texas A & M Kingsville | NCAA DII | |
| Luke Lamb | Dakota State | NAIA DII | |
| Miha Glavas | Arkansas Fort Smith | NCAA DII | |
| K.J. Evans | Wisconsin Whitewater | NCAA III | |
| 2010 | L.C. Doss | Eastern Illinois | NCAA DI |
| Vontrell Seroyer | Wayne State | NCAA DII | |
| Damon Smith | University of Mary | NCAA DII | |
| Cornelius Mosby | University of Minnesota-Crookston | NCAA DII | |
| John Wolfe | University of Texas-Permian Basin | NCAA DII | |
| 2009 | Tony Lewis | Illinois State University | NCAA DI |
| Mike Candelaria | Francis Marion | NCAA DII | |
| Brad Starkin | Wayne State | NCAA DII | |
| Nick Wagner | Grandview | NAIA | |
| Nathan Muench | Grandview | NAIA | |
| 2008 | Edin Suljic | Eastern Illinois | NCAA DI |
| Tom Boyle | Minnesota State-Moorhead | NCAA DII | |
| 2007 | David Trumblee | Mount Mercy | NAIA |
| 2006 | Chuol Chany | Concordia University | NCAA DII |
| Rohan Greaves | Grandview | NAIA | |
| 2005 | Kye Pattrick | Loyola-Chicago | NCAA DI |
| Denis Ikovlev | University of Nevada | NCAA DI | |
| Steffan Williams | Judson University | NAIA | |
| Salum Rajabu | Minnesota State-Moorehad | NCAA DII | |
| Leif Hetzler | Upper Iowa | NCAA DII | |
| 2004 | DJ Warren | Culver Stockton | NAIA |
| 2003 | Aboubacar Conde | Minot State | NAIA |
| Andre Tarpley | University of Nebraska-Omaha | NCAA DII | |
| 2002 | Anthony Styles | Park University | NAIA |
| Tim Parham | Maryland-Eastern Shore | NCAA DI | |
| 2001 | Lloyd Flanders | Minot State | NAIA |
| 2000 | Jason Pershing | Mount Mercy College | NAIA |